If categories have always felt like a bit of a mystery, you are in good company. It’s one of the conversations I have with almost every client, whether we’re working on a website design or a brand. Categories are hard to set in stone, especially when you’re still figuring out your content.
The good news is that this is much more doable than it sounds. Here’s how I walk my clients through it, from how many categories to have to what to do if you’ve never given yours a second thought.

Categories vs. tags: what’s the difference?
This is confusing for a lot of people, and that’s because categories and tags are pretty much the same thing at their core. The main difference is that categories can have a hierarchy. You can have a parent category like Desserts, with subcategories like Brownies, Cookies, and Cakes underneath it. Tags are one layer only, so you can’t stack them.
Because they do such similar jobs, I recommend using tags only behind the scenes. They’re great for things like ingredients, or a tag for sponsored posts so you can filter them in your dashboard. I just wouldn’t show them on the front of your site.
I also recommend noindexing your tags, which a lot of SEOs suggest too. That simply means telling Google not to show those pages in search results. Google doesn’t care whether content is a category, a page, or a post. It cares about whether it’s the best content. Having both categories and tags mostly just confuses you as the blogger without adding any extra value.
Start with your niche
Before you touch a single category, zoom out and think about your niche. Your niche is not just “food blogger.” Even if you run a healthy food blog, there’s another layer that sets you apart from the 10 other healthy food bloggers out there. Food blogging is competitive these days, so getting clear on this and sticking with it really matters.
Once you know your niche, think about how you’d break it down even further. If you run a healthy food on a budget blog, you might organize by price point, course, main ingredient, or dietary preference. There are lots of ways to slice it.
One thing to watch for is getting so specific that a category competes with one of your own posts. You probably don’t need a chicken parmesan category unless you have many, many variations of it. In most cases, chicken parmesan is a post that lives inside a larger category. A post will almost always be a better resource for someone searching for chicken parmesan than a category page.

Try the 20 post exercise
Here’s my favorite way to figure out how specific your categories should be. Pull up your 20 most recent blog posts. That’s a great sample of what you typically publish.
Now imagine you have a sticky note for each one. How would you start grouping them? By the main protein? By course, like lunch, dinner, and dessert? By dietary need? The way you naturally sort them tells you a lot about what your categories should look like.
If your 20 posts don’t have much in common, try going one level higher in how you think about your content. I’d guess most of you will see at least a few clear groups.
Think about how readers will experience your categories
Next, look at your site from the outside. Picture someone who found you on Pinterest or Google and landed on one of your posts. Their next stop is often your homepage, and they’re looking for two things: what your site is all about and who is behind it.
Your homepage shouldn’t be only your most recent posts. It should help people understand your main categories and the kind of content you share. If your 20 posts turned out to be about half easy weeknight dinners and half desserts, that’s a clue for how to organize your homepage.
Your recipe index is the other big one. Between the homepage and the recipe index, those two pages give a new reader a snapshot of what to expect from you, which makes them a great lens for deciding which categories you need.
Related Episodes: EP 160: 3 Things For Your Homepage & EP 217: 3 Things To Do With Your Recipe Index
How many categories do you need?
The clearest answer I can give you is that it depends, mostly on how many posts you have. If you only have 20 posts, this isn’t something to stress about yet. It’s helpful to have an idea of the categories you’d like to fill out eventually, but you want your categories to be as full as possible. Skip categories with just one or two posts unless you plan to build them out in the next few months. One muffin recipe doesn’t need a Muffins category unless that’s a direction you know you’re heading.
A helpful starting point comes from Feast Design Co, the creators of the Foodie Pro theme. They suggest about one category for every 10 posts, so with 200 posts, up to 20 categories is fine. They also recommend keeping each category to 20 posts or fewer so you don’t end up with multiple pages per category. I like that as a goal, but it’s not very practical for my clients who have been blogging for 5 to 10 years and have 500 to 1,000 posts. Their categories often land at 40 to 50 posts each, and that’s okay as long as the content is easy to find.
I’d aim for at least 4 to 5 posts before you create a category, and remember you can always add categories to older posts later.
Categories can also be a content planning tool. Look for the ones that are a little thin, then plan new posts over the next 6 months to fill them out. Readers get more to choose from while they browse, and every new post fits right into your niche and your bigger blog vision.

Fill out your category pages
Each category page should have a description. Most good themes show it automatically on the category page, so you shouldn’t need extra code. If yours doesn’t, check whether your theme has a second place to add one. It’s often called an archive description, and switching to that box can solve the problem.
Write the description with keywords in mind. It helps Google understand what your site is about and can help you rank for that topic. This is another reason not to get too specific with your categories, since a very specific category can end up competing with your own recipe post.
Cleaning up a category mess: make a spreadsheet
If you’re listening to all this and thinking, “I have no idea what I’ve created,” a spreadsheet can help. I’m not usually a spreadsheet person, but looking at categories this way makes a big difference.
Create a sheet with three columns:
- Category name
- How many posts are in it
- Category description
From there, you can pull in any descriptions you already have and improve them, or write new ones. This is a great job to do while you’re watching Netflix, or to hand off to someone on your team. As you go, look for categories that can go.
Deleting old categories without creating a 404
Before you delete a category, check whether it’s getting any traffic. If it is, set up a redirect to a page that makes more sense instead of leaving visitors on a 404 page. If it’s a category you created on a whim that has nothing to do with your site now, you don’t need to worry about a redirect.
It feels so good to get this cleaned up. You really don’t need 70 categories when you only have 70 blog posts.
What to do next
Take a step back and look at your blog as a whole. Sort your posts on paper or in your spreadsheet first, then make the changes in WordPress. Once you see how everything fits together, categories help you with so much more than organization. They sharpen the direction of your blog, show you what to create next, and make your homepage, recipe index, and internal linking easier to plan.
If your categories, homepage, and recipe index don’t feel like they’re working together, that’s exactly the kind of thing we love untangling at Grace + Vine Studios. You can learn more at our services page or reach out and tell us a little about your blog and what you’d like to fix!

ready to take your food blog to the next level?
We work with food bloggers looking to stand out of the crowd through custom brand and website design.
topics
Browse through some of the topics we discuss on the blog, then click over to see all the posts within that topic!

hey friend, i’m madison
Food blogger turned web designer
I’ve been where you are. Growing fast, feeling overwhelmed by the tech side of things, and realizing that somewhere between hitting 100k sessions and launching that new revenue stream, the foundations of your business got left behind.
I started out as a food blogger, so I get it. The constant juggling. The feeling that your site doesn’t match who you’ve become. The frustration of working way too hard while your brand and tech hold you back.
That’s why I created Grace + Vine Studios—to help monetized food bloggers like you finally catch up. Whether it’s your branding, your website, or just figuring out what the heck comes next, I’m here to help you build a business that reflects where you are now and actually improves your life instead of consuming it.


So helpful! Thank you. I had many years of recipes posted but not a good back-end organization of them which led to plenty of confusion on how to categorize everything. This helps me to have a clear picture moving forward.